Top 20 Horror Movies You Probably Haven't Seen (2023 Update)

Another year has come and gone and we are back to ARKTOBER, so bring on the horror movies! Every year I like to shout out some of my favorite genre’s hidden gems, so below is my annual article, updated with some new quality flicks. Enjoy 2023’s 20 Best Horror Movies You Probably haven’t seen! 

It’s the most wonderful time of the year! Not because you can finally get your pumpkin-spiced everything that you’ve been waiting for, though that certainly doesn’t hurt. Not because the leaves are starting to change to beautiful colors. Tis’ the season of Halloween, bringing with it the annual bingeing of our favorite spooky stories, but great horror movies can be hard to find. So here is a list of my personal favorites that you probably haven’t seen. (less than 50,000 ratings on IMDB). So let’s get to it.

20. The Devil’s Candy (2015) - 21,106 Streaming on AMC+ / tubi

This compact gem wastes no time in delivering spine-tingling moments that will undoubtedly make you squirm in your seat. It pays a stylish homage to the occult sub-genre, demonstrating its ability to blend dark themes with a pulsating narrative. The film is a testament to the talent of director Sean Byrne, who continues to build a formidable resume in the horror realm. In its brevity and style, 'The Devil's Candy' packs a punch, reminding us that horror can be both thrilling and immensely entertaining. While it may not be a nightmare-inducing masterpiece, it is a compelling addition to the genre and guarantees a devilishly good time.

19. Infinity Pool (2023) - 42,520 Streaming on Hulu

It's easy at first glance to right off Infinity Pool as only a striking and wild exercise in hedonism and violence; but as you sit with it longer and explore the world that steps just outside of our own, we start to reflect our own humanity and what we're willing to sacrifice for what we think we want. Mia Goth proves, once again, that she's a force to be reckoned with while Brandon Cronenberg continues to deliver jaw-dropping, provocative visual horror. 'Infinity Pool' basks in a world of debauchery while simultaneously questioning and condemning that exact world along the way, and I think it works.

18. One Cut of the Dead (2017) - 27,940 Streaming on AMC+

At first glance, 'One Cut of the Dead' might appear as if it's crafted by film students with limited resources, but it rapidly evolves into a remarkably creative addition to the zombie movie genre. This film not only brings a refreshing level of wit and inventiveness to a somewhat oversaturated subgenre but also pays homage to its predecessors with genuine respect. However, it's essential not to underestimate it. While it may initially come across as a low-budget horror-comedy, 'One Cut of the Dead' surprises with some of the most ingenious camera work seen in recent memory. Its ability to seamlessly blend humor, horror, and intricate cinematography is truly remarkable, finding itself to be an enchanting revelation that both zombie movie enthusiasts and cinephiles should not overlook.

17. Possessor (2020) - 42,836 Streaming on Hulu

For a second time on this list, Brandon Cronenberg delivers an enthralling cinematic experience with 'Possessor,' a fever dream that masterfully fuses cerebral complexity with unflinching brutality. This relentless odyssey plunges audiences into an outlandish yet eerily grounded realm, challenging our own perceptions of reality. The performances are nothing short of brilliant, breathing life into a dark and blood-soaked narrative that will undoubtedly leave viewers in a state of profound shock and awe.

16. Eyes Without A Face (1960) - 33,890 Streaming on MAX

"Eyes Without a Face" remains a haunting and enduring example of cinematic storytelling, presenting a chilling fairy tale of guilt and obsession that, even sixty-three years after its release, continues to captivate and terrify audiences. This classic film weaves a tapestry of poetic horror, its impact undiminished by the passage of time. Director Georges Franju's delicate yet macabre touch casts an eerie spell over the audience, leaving us haunted by the film's unsettling imagery.

15. Lake Mungo (2008) - 26,609 Streaming on AMC+ / tubi

This Australian mockumentary-style horror-thriller captivates from start to finish, offering a fresh take on the genre, with storytelling that is masterfully executed, presenting its narrative through a combination of interviews, home videos, and faux-documentary footage. Incredibly grounded performances work intandem with this framework, creating an unsettling realism that draws you deeper into the mystery surrounding the Palmer family, with slow-burn pacing that allows tension to simmer beneath the surface, creating an atmosphere of lingering unease.

14. She Dies Tomorrow (2020) - 6,883 Streaming on Hulu

"She Dies Tomorrow" is a unique and divisive horror film that has garnered attention for its unconventional approach to the genre, while exploring the idea of contagious existential dread. Instead of relying on jump scares and gore, the film focuses on the psychological horror of impending doom and unrelenting anxiety, delving into the characters' psyches and exploring how fear can manifest for each individual. Atmospheric and dreamlike visuals cultivate an eerie and immersive world while strong performances from its cast, including Kate Lyn Sheil and Jane Adams, enhancing the emotional depth of the characters and their experiences. It's important to note that "She Dies Tomorrow" might not be everyone's cup of tea due to its deliberate pacing and abstract narrative style. Some viewers might even perceive it as more of a thought-provoking drama than a traditional horror movie. However, if you're drawn to the idea of an atmospheric horror that challenges the norms of the genre, then it is an absolute must-watch.

13. Host (2020) - 35,962 Streaming on AMC+

This is not the first time that conference-call cinema has been used but it is certainly the most effective attempt that I’ve seen. Rob Savage and his team have delivered a quarantine flick that is tonally spot-on while delivering genuinely creepy jump scares and some brutal imagery. The short runtime allows for this flick to give you feature-length frights without overstaying its welcome.

12. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night (2014) - 37,559 RENTAL

"A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night" is a genre-bending vampire film that defies conventions and delivers a story that's equal parts romantic, emotional, and downright creepy. Ana Lily Amirpour's directorial debut is nothing short of remarkable, and it's a film that demands your attention. It's not just a vampire film; it's a character study, a love story, and a commentary on societal norms all rolled into one. Ana Lily Amirpour's direction is confident and visionary as she crafts a unique atmosphere that oozes with style and originality. 

11. Tigers Are Not Afraid (2019) - 8,441 Streaming on AMC+

"Tigers Are Not Afraid" is a hauntingly beautiful and emotionally charged film that transcends genre boundaries to deliver a profound experience. Director Issa López has crafted a dark fairy tale that leaves an indelible mark on the viewer's soul as it weaves a poignant and heartbreaking narrative around the lives of a group of orphaned children in a Mexican city plagued by violence. The film's blend of magical realism, deeply rooted in Mexican folklore and stark realism offers a unique perspective on the harsh realities faced by these young group of heroes that should be in the same conversation as films like Pan’s Labyrinth and Spirited Away.

10. You Won’t Be Alone (2022) - 9,689 Streaming on Peacock

Think less of traditional horror and more Brother’s Grimm fairytale, but regardless on how you classify “You Won’t Be Alone”, it’s certainly worth the watch. Goren Stolevski uses classic folk-horror imagery and lore to tell as story that beautifully explores the idea of legacy and the impact that we have on others, recognizing that wickedness may not only be the cause of witches. It’s hypnotic and poetic, while beautifully (and sometimes horrifically) balancing all the humanity and gore.

9. The Dark and The Wicked (2020) - 20,498 Streaming on AMC+

Director Bryan Bertino masterfully crafts a harrowing atmosphere that seeps into your bones, creating an atmosphere so thick with dread that you can practically taste it. From the eerie isolation of the rural farm setting to the ominous presence lurking just out of sight, every aspect of the film is designed to keep you on edge. Marin Ireland and Michael Abbott Jr. deliver standout performances as the troubled siblings grappling with their own personal demons while confronting the malevolent force that has descended upon their family. Their portrayals are raw and emotionally charged, giving such weight to these individuals who are trapped in a nightmarish situation.

8. Black Christmas (1974) - 45,171 Streaming on AMC+ / Peacock / Pluto / tubi / Roku Channel / etc.

When you think of incredible slasher movies, it's unfortunate that 'Black Christmas' (1974) often gets left out of the conversation alongside the more celebrated classics. This oversight is a true disservice, for 'Black Christmas' stands as a cornerstone of the genre. Directed by the talented Bob Clark and featuring Olivia Hussey, Margot Kidder, and John Saxon among others, it's a film that has left an indelible mark on horror cinema. What sets 'Black Christmas' apart is its unsettling dialogue and gritty portrayal of terror as obscene phone calls escalate into something far more sinister. Nearly 50 years after its release, 'Black Christmas' still holds its own as a must-watch for any fan of the slasher sub-genre. It's a gripping and atmospheric experience that laid the groundwork for the horrors that followed, making it a classic that deserves its place among the genre's greats.

7. The Loved Ones (2009) - 43,044 Streaming on Paramount+ / Pluto TV

Sean Byrne's directorial prowess shines through once again in this film that's so horrifically mesmerizing it's impossible to look away. With a relentless stream of shocking and jaw-dropping scenes, this movie pushes the boundaries of your comfort zone and keeps you hooked from start to finish. "The Loved Ones" is a twisted and unforgettable ride that leaves you questioning your own sanity for continuing to watch. It's a testament to Byrne's talent that he can craft a narrative so utterly disturbing yet utterly compelling. It’s a wild ride that is certainly worth taking.

6. Honeymoon (2014) - 26,897 Streaming on Roku Channel

"Honeymoon" (2014) is a seriously spine-tingling film that'll leave you creeped out for days. Rose Leslie and Harry Treadaway put on a hell of a show, making the horror hit way too close to home as it digs deep into the idea of getting lost in our own relationships. The story unfolds as a honeymoon turns into a nightmare, and you won't shake off the eerie feeling it leaves behind. Director Leigh Janiak nails the psychological horror, and the remote woodland setting adds a perfect creepy backdrop. "Honeymoon" isn't just about fear; it's about love gone wrong taking what we assume to be safe and making it anything but.

5. Thirst (2009) - 49,998 RENTAL

"Thirst" injects a much-needed dose of vitality into the Vampire sub-genre, which has often suffered from uninspired treatments. Chan-Wook Park, who may be my favorite working Director, takes the reins of this narrative and transforms it into a breathtaking masterpiece. The film not only reimagines the vampire mythos but also delves deep into the complexities of desire, morality, and human nature. Park's vision is nothing short of spellbinding, making every frame a work of art that lingers in your memory. With his unparalleled ability to craft visually stunning scenes, he elevates "Thirst" to a level of excellence in a way that only he could. 

4. Murder Party (2007) - 12,051 Streaming on Pluto TV / tubi

The Horror/Comedy sub-genre is a treasure trove of exceptional films, and among these gems, "Murder Party" stands as a shining example of brilliance. Serving as Jeremy Saulnier's directorial debut, it is a tour de force of humor and horror, masterfully blending those elements and offering a unique and unforgettable viewing experience, delivering a climax that is horrifyingly thrilling. It's a testament to Saulnier's creative vision and his ability to surprise and captivate his audience.

3. Speak No Evil (2022) - 30,645 Streaming on AMC+

Placing Speak No Evil this high on the list feels, for lack of a better word, icky. Performances are pitch-perfect. Themes around respectability politics in times of crisis resonate deeply. It is disturbing, infuriating, and holds zero punches. I say this without an ounce of hyperbole; this is one of the most disturbing watches in the last 20 years. Approach this movie with an abundance of caution because as someone who watched it over a year ago, it still haunts me.

2. Watcher (2022) - 36,605 Streaming on AMC+ / Hulu

Chloe Okuno presents us with a coldly gorgeous film that perfectly modernizes the Hitchcockian thriller. “Watcher” is a  bleak and purposefully unkind look into navigating anxiety in a patriarchal world. A world that constantly invalidates the experience of women, taking the protagonist, masterfully played by Maika Monroe, and the audience through feelings of doubt and unease, with a finale that had me out of my seat.

1. The House of the Devil (2009) - 49,840 Streaming on Peacock / Pluto TV / tubi

What's truly remarkable is how "House of the Devil" manages to feel both familiar and incredibly unique at the same time. While paying homage to the classics of 70’s horror, it carves its own distinct path, offering viewers an experience that is both nostalgic and fresh. It's a rare achievement in the horror genre. "House of the Devil" is more than just a movie; it's an immersion into a bygone era of horror. In a world where many horror films rely on cheap thrills and excessive gore, this one stands out as a must-watch for anyone who appreciates the art of suspense, atmosphere, and masterful storytelling.